The Friction of Accountability: Why Local Governance Shouldn’t Be a “Quiet Club”

Public service is often described as a thankless task, usually undertaken by volunteers or those with a deep-seated desire to help their community. However, there is a dangerous misconception that because local representatives are often “part-time,” the standards of their work should be anything less than professional.

Lately, I have been reflecting on just how difficult it is to uphold the principles of accountability within a small local authority. It is a painful learning process, and it requires a thick skin.

The “Duty of the Record”

At the heart of any democracy is the public record—the minutes. These are not just notes; they are the legal history of how public money is spent and how decisions are made. If the minutes are inaccurate, incomplete, or “sanitized” to avoid controversy, the public loses its ability to hold its representatives to account.

Insisting on accuracy is often seen as “being difficult.” It creates friction. It makes meetings longer. But as public servants, our primary duty is to the residents, not to the comfort of the boardroom. If we cannot get the record of our meetings right, how can the public trust us to get the big decisions right?

Transparency vs. “Private Sessions”

There is a growing, concerning trend toward moving difficult discussions into “private sessions.” While the law allows for privacy in specific cases—such as personnel matters or legal advice—transparency must remain the default.

When public business is moved behind closed doors without a strict legal necessity, it risks becoming a “quiet club” where accountability is traded for convenience. A board that is afraid of public scrutiny is a board that is failing its mandate. We are elected to serve in the light, not to orchestrate outcomes in the dark.

The Road to Outstanding

My ultimate goal has never been about “winning” an argument; it has been about service. I firmly believe that our parish has the potential to move from ‘satisfactory’ to ‘outstanding.’ However, this transformation requires a board that is willing to acknowledge its own errors, correct its records, and prioritize transparency above personal defense.

If the price of moving our services forward is my own departure, provided the public record is corrected and our governance is set on the right path then I am prepared to pay that price. True public service is not about holding onto a seat; it is about ensuring that the systems we leave behind are better, more transparent, and more effective than the ones we found.

The High Price of Standing Up

Advocating for higher standards is not a popular path. It often results in internal pushback, procedural maneuvers, or even formal warnings intended to stifle dissent.

I acknowledge that this pursuit of accuracy can be intense. It is a challenge to balance the need for collaboration with the absolute necessity of procedural integrity. However, the alternative, silence in the face of mediocrity, is a far greater risk to our community.

Moving Forward

The residents of Patrick deserve a local authority that is beyond reproach. We should welcome the friction of debate and the scrutiny of the public. Accountability isn’t a burden to be managed; it is the very foundation of the trust the public places in us.

If we want to move our community forward, we must first ensure we are standing on a foundation of truth and transparency. Anything less is a disservice to the people we represent.

Reminder to vote Card important issues as decided by voters 2021 in Glenfaba & Peel

The following were assumed that they were a priority:

Sewerage works, Silt in the harbor, Stem Cell Block, Elderly Care home, Road surfaces, Clothworkers school refurbishment.

The issue here under were filled in on the reminder to vote card below and handed in at the polling station. All great issues.

  • Elder Persons Champion
  • Wifi Speed for rural areas
  • Residential Care in the West
  • Glen Maye Hub/Cafe/Play area for children x 2
  • £5 per a month Health Insurance
  • Peat Free Compost
  • Less plastic packaging
  • Low cost renewable energy
  • Mole support for local producers/ less imports
  • Work Permits reinstated
  • Apprenticeships for local youth, more job opportunity
  • Sewerage at Reayrt ny Cronk
  • Better Bus Service
  • Plant more Trees & Wild Flowers
  • NHS Crisis
  • Affordable Housing
  • Increase minimum wage
  • Improved Cycle-ways
  • More transparency in health
  • Better Recycling
  • Diversify economy
  • National Living Wage
  • Increase transparency in all areas
  • More investment in Peel
  • Climate change
  • Adult mental health
  • Child care support
  • Carbon neutral new housing/buildings
  • Sustainable and Ethically based economy
  • A sense of global responsibility regarding refugees
  • Impending gas price increase
  • Bring down cost of electric cars
  • Repeal the abortion law it goes too far, needs amending
  • Increase in financial help to employers to give apprenticeship
  • Repair and extend sewerage pipe at end of the breakwater
  • No more housing estates until sewerage works is done.
  • Act on learning’s from Douglas promenade.
  • Be more transparent with public
  • Closer look at managing internal cost
  • Fit for Purpose banking in Peel
  • Bus services that support local areas
  • Implementation of hate crime laws
  • Better infrastructure for cycling
  • Grants for insulation & solar energy
  • Attempt to reduce road traffic
  • Boost local food production
  • Improved Medical Health Services GP & Hospital